What Does Santa Really Want With His Cookies?
Cookies are wonderful. But after visiting homes all over the world on Christmas Eve, Santa might tell you that the sweetest part isn't what's on the plate.
Leaving cookies for Santa is one of those Christmas traditions children seem to understand instinctively.
Santa is coming all the way to our house?
Of course we should feed him.
And after all that traveling, Santa certainly isn't going to turn down a good cookie.
But if you ask what Santa really loves about the tradition, it may have less to do with chocolate chips and more to do with the little person who carefully chose the plate.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
1. Does Santa Have a Favorite Cookie?
This is one of the questions Santa gets asked a lot.
The safe North Pole answer is: Santa appreciates every cookie.
Chocolate chip is hard to argue with. Sugar cookies are a Christmas classic. Gingerbread certainly looks festive. Peanut butter cookies have their loyal fans.
But the best cookie may simply be the one your family likes enough to leave for Santa.
If your child proudly helped bake it, decorated it or picked it out, that makes it even better.
2. Homemade Is Lovely—but Absolutely Not Required
Please do not add “bake perfect cookies from scratch” to your Christmas Eve stress list because you think Santa expects it.
He does not.
Store-bought cookies are perfectly respectable North Pole cuisine.
So are refrigerated cookie dough cookies.
So are the slightly lopsided cookies your six-year-old covered with an unreasonable quantity of sprinkles.
Actually, Santa has a soft spot for those.
3. Add a Note for Santa
This may be the thing Santa enjoys most.
Leave a little note beside the plate.
It can say:
- Thank you, Santa!
- We hope you like the cookies.
- Safe travels tonight!
- Please tell Rudolph hello.
- We love you, Santa.
Young children can draw a picture instead.
Those notes turn a plate of cookies into a conversation between a child and Santa.
Santa letter sets and North Pole stationery can make notes to Santa feel extra special.
Browse Santa stationery on Amazon (paid link)4. What About the Milk?
Milk is traditional, but Santa is flexible.
Families around the world leave different drinks and treats depending on their own traditions.
If your household doesn't drink milk, don't buy a carton just for Santa.
Water, cocoa or another family-friendly drink can work just fine.
Santa has a very long route. Hydration is important.
5. Don't Forget the Reindeer
Santa gets the cookies, but the reindeer are doing a fair amount of work too.
A few carrots are the classic choice.
Children can leave them beside Santa's snack or outside where the reindeer can find them.
If you make “reindeer food,” stick with wildlife-safe ingredients such as oats and edible sprinkles. Avoid craft glitter or anything animals shouldn't eat.
6. Use a Special Santa Plate
A Santa cookie plate can become one of those small traditions children remember.
Bring out the same plate every Christmas Eve.
Let the children arrange the cookies.
Take a picture of them with it each year.
Someday the plate itself may become part of the family's Christmas story.
Personalized Santa cookie plates and milk sets are easy to reuse year after year.
Browse Santa cookie plates on Amazon (paid link)7. How Many Cookies Does Santa Need?
Santa visits an extraordinary number of houses.
He probably does not need twelve cookies at every stop.
Two or three is plenty.
One carefully decorated masterpiece can also be enough.
Remember, the tradition is about the gesture—not creating a late-night cookie-eating endurance event for Santa.
8. Make Sure Santa Leaves Evidence
This is where parents sometimes become part of the North Pole support team.
In the morning, children love discovering:
- A bite missing from a cookie
- An empty milk glass
- A half-eaten carrot
- A note from Santa
- A few crumbs on the plate
That little bit of evidence makes Christmas morning feel much more convincing.
Just make sure the family dog isn't the one producing the evidence.
9. Leave a Tiny Reply From Santa
If your child left Santa a note, consider leaving a short response.
It doesn't need to be elaborate.
Something as simple as:
“Thank you for the delicious cookies! Rudolph loved his carrot. Merry Christmas! Love, Santa.”
can create enormous excitement.
Keep the note afterward and tuck it into your Christmas memory box.
10. Let Your Family Make the Tradition Its Own
Maybe your family leaves brownies.
Maybe Grandma's Christmas cookies.
Maybe Santa gets a slice of pie.
Maybe there's always cocoa in a particular mug.
There are families in different parts of the world who leave Santa all kinds of things.
The details don't have to match anyone else's tradition.
That's what makes family traditions wonderful.
11. The Real Treat Is the Thought Behind It
A plate of cookies is a child's way of participating in Christmas.
They aren't simply waiting for Santa to bring something to them.
They're thinking about Santa too.
They're preparing something.
They're giving something.
They're saying thank you.
And that's a pretty lovely lesson tucked inside a very simple Christmas Eve tradition.
So What Does Santa Really Want?
A cookie would be nice.
Chocolate chip is always a strong contender.
But Santa would probably be just as happy with a slightly burned sugar cookie decorated by a four-year-old and a note that says:
“Dear Santa, I made this for you.”
Because that's the part that makes it Christmas magic.
Make Santa Part of Your Christmas Story
Santa Tim & Mrs. Claus Robbin create personal Christmas experiences for families, neighborhoods, businesses, schools, churches and community celebrations throughout Jacksonville and Florida's First Coast.
Check Santa & Mrs. Claus Availability